Hi Speedwell,
I never considered this to be anything but fiction. Actually, I'm kinda surprised that anyone would respond to it in any other way, but maybe I missed something (I have to admit that I didn't try to research it as you have). Consequently, my critiques are based on it as a work of fiction derived from currently circulating ideas and testimonies regarding the arc from death through the between-lives realm to rebirth. In this case, the narrative of these three stages is framed by semi-realistic "pre" and "post" lifetime accounts--serving as "introduction" and "postlude". However, overall, I evaluate it as "art" rather than "history". In that regard, I'm more interested in the visual aspects than the story line. E.g., I like the way the "artist/storyteller" does the animation via interesting line drawings, and then fills them in with washes of color.
Still, it had its problems. And, I thought the ending was a bit dopey. I.e., for me there is a bit of a clash between the idea that the protagonist has now achieved some degree of spiritual enlightenment, but his main goal in life seems to be surfing and getting things on with a bevy of beautiful bikini clad babes. So, enlightenment leads to self-absorbed hedonism? I'm not opposed to surfing or the fairer sex. I loved surfing once upon a time, and found my own wonderful girl to marry. However, with this supposedly much wiser spirit I would have expected something a bit less hedonistic and a bit more altruistic.
Anyhow, that is my "take" on the video as an interesting, but only semi-satisfying "fictional" animated short story.
Cordially,
S&S