Hi
I'm looking for Leonard Angel's critique of The Imad Elawar Case, which was published in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994.
Can anyone help?
....
I haven't read the original case yet, but I think this'll be an interesting one, because as far as I can see it's the case with the most back-and-forth with people saying "That ain't so – this is so." Etc.
It looks like there might be more critique on this case than there is on other cases – and I'd like to make sure I get all the critiques.
Here's a list of the critiques etc – maybe you can't help out with my question, but you might be interested in this list:
-- The Imad Elawar Case is in Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation (1966 and 1974) – that's on Amazon.
-- The case was then critiqued by Leonard Angel in an article in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994 – this is the item I can't find. Can anyone help out with this?
-- There's then this: Ian Stevenson Replies to Leonard Angel
http://www.scribd.com/doc/213438894/Ian-Stevenson-Replies-to-Leonard-Angel#scribd
-- And then this: Another Look at The Imad Elawar Case - A Review of Leonard Angel's Critique of This "Past Life Memory Case Study"
http://www.criticandokardec.com.br/imad_elawar_revisited.html#tabulations
I'm looking for Leonard Angel's critique of The Imad Elawar Case, which was published in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994.
Can anyone help?
....
I haven't read the original case yet, but I think this'll be an interesting one, because as far as I can see it's the case with the most back-and-forth with people saying "That ain't so – this is so." Etc.
It looks like there might be more critique on this case than there is on other cases – and I'd like to make sure I get all the critiques.
Here's a list of the critiques etc – maybe you can't help out with my question, but you might be interested in this list:
-- The Imad Elawar Case is in Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation (1966 and 1974) – that's on Amazon.
-- The case was then critiqued by Leonard Angel in an article in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994 – this is the item I can't find. Can anyone help out with this?
-- There's then this: Ian Stevenson Replies to Leonard Angel
http://www.scribd.com/doc/213438894/Ian-Stevenson-Replies-to-Leonard-Angel#scribd
-- And then this: Another Look at The Imad Elawar Case - A Review of Leonard Angel's Critique of This "Past Life Memory Case Study"
http://www.criticandokardec.com.br/imad_elawar_revisited.html#tabulations