Question about the Imad Elawar Case in Ian Stevenson's Twenty Cases Suggestive of Rei

[Richar]

Hi

I'm looking for Leonard Angel's critique of The Imad Elawar Case, which was published in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994.

Can anyone help?

....


I haven't read the original case yet, but I think this'll be an interesting one, because as far as I can see it's the case with the most back-and-forth with people saying "That ain't so – this is so." Etc.

It looks like there might be more critique on this case than there is on other cases – and I'd like to make sure I get all the critiques.

Here's a list of the critiques etc – maybe you can't help out with my question, but you might be interested in this list:

-- The Imad Elawar Case is in Twenty Cases Suggestive of Reincarnation (1966 and 1974) – that's on Amazon.

-- The case was then critiqued by Leonard Angel in an article in the Skeptical Inquirer Magazine in 1994 – this is the item I can't find. Can anyone help out with this?

-- There's then this: Ian Stevenson Replies to Leonard Angel
http://www.scribd.com/doc/213438894/Ian-Stevenson-Replies-to-Leonard-Angel#scribd

-- And then this: Another Look at The Imad Elawar Case - A Review of Leonard Angel's Critique of This "Past Life Memory Case Study"
http://www.criticandokardec.com.br/imad_elawar_revisited.html#tabulations

 

[argonne1918]

There is a facebook page called "Signs of Reincarnation". There are several researchers there that I think can help you with this. I think they said Jim Tucker is also part of that group. It's a closed and moderated group, but you won't have any problems joining them.

 

[jonathan21]

Hi can you still join a closed and moderated group?

 

[argonne1918]

Yes. This is how they screen out people who just want to harass and ridicule people. They will usually let anyone join, but if you start to bully or put people down they will ban you.

 

[Richar]

Thanks. I joined that group, and I'll post the question there.