• Thank you to Carol and Steve Bowman, the forum owners, for our new upgrade!

Could a Little Boy Be Proof of Reincarnation?

Could a Little Boy Be Proof of Reincarnation?


From the ABC News story, "Could a Little Boy Be Proof of Reincarnation?"

ABC News
April 15, 2004


Nearly six decades ago, a 21-year-old Navy fighter pilot on a mission over the Pacific was shot down by Japanese artillery. His name might have been forgotten, were it not for 6-year-old James Leininger.


Quite a few people — including those who knew the fighter pilot — think James is the pilot, reincarnated. James' parents, Andrea and Bruce, a highly educated, modern couple, say they are "probably the people least likely to have a scenario like this pop up in their lives." But over time, they have become convinced their little son has had a former life.


From an early age, James would play with nothing else but planes, his parents say. But when he was 2, they said the planes their son loved began to give him regular nightmares. "I'd wake him up and he'd be screaming," Andrea told ABCNEWS' Chris Cuomo. She said when she asked her son what he was dreaming about, he would say, "Airplane crash on fire, little man can't get out."


Reality Check


Andrea says her mom was the first to suggest James was remembering a past life. At first, Andrea says she was doubtful. James was only watching kids' shows, his parents say, and they weren't watching World War II documentaries or conversing about military history. But as time went by, Andrea began to wonder what to believe. In one video of James at age 3, he goes over a plane as if he's doing a preflight check.


Another time, Andrea said, she bought him a toy plane, and pointed out what appeared to be a bomb on its underside. She says James corrected her, and told her it was a drop tank. "I'd never heard of a drop tank," she said. "I didn't know what a drop tank was."


Then James' violent nightmares got worse, occurring three and four times a week. Andrea's mother suggested she look into the work of counselor and therapist Carol Bowman, who believes that the dead sometimes can be reborn.


With guidance from Bowman, they began to encourage James to share his memories — and immediately, Andrea says, the nightmares started become less frequent. James was also becoming more articulate about his apparent past, she said.


Bowman said James was at the age when former lives are most easily recalled. "They haven't had the cultural conditioning, the layering over the experience in this life so the memories can percolate up more easily," she said.


Trail of Mysteries


Over time, James' parents say he revealed extraordinary details about the life of a former fighter pilot — mostly at bedtime, when he was drowsy. They say James told them his plane had been hit by the Japanese and crashed. Andrea says James told his father he flew a Corsair, and then told her, "They used to get flat tires all the time." In fact, historians and pilots agree that the plane's tires took a lot of punishment on landing. But that's a fact that could easily be found in books or on television.


Andrea says James also told his father the name of the boat he took off from — Natoma — and the name of someone he flew with — "Jack Larson." After some research, Bruce discovered both the Natoma and Jack Larson were real. The Natoma Bay was a small aircraft carrier in the Pacific. And Larson is living in Arkansas. "It was like, holy mackerel," Bruce said. "You could have poured my brains out of my ears. I just couldn't believe it.
Leninger.jpg



James Leininger


Leninger2.jpg



James Huston Jr., in 1944. One year before he was shot down.
 
Who was James Huston, Jr.?

Pittsburgh Live said:
James Huston was born Oct. 22, 1923, in South Bend, Ind., and lived in Uniontown during the 1930s. His father was James McCready Huston Sr., of Brownsville, and Daryl Green Huston, who was born in New Geneva and grew up in Uniontown. James was the only son.
James Huston's plane was hit in the engine by Japanese fire on March 3, 1945, went down in flames and sank immediately. Flyer Jack Larson witnessed the crash.


According to Lt. Huston's cousin, Bob Huston of Flatwoods, the elder Huston started several newspapers and published 13 books. He was living in Brownsville when two Navy officers informed Huston of his son's death.


"I didn't know James," Bob Huston said. His parents were divorced, "but I knew his father. He stayed with us in Brownsville. James was on his 50th mission and would have come home if he'd lived another five minutes."


The Leiningers have been in touch with Bob Huston.


"I knew what happened to James (Huston)," he said. "I was excited to hear from them (the Leiningers). The boy's mother was flabbergasted when all this happened."


Andrea believes that her son is the reincarnation of Lt. James Huston. "There are so many little things. I believe in reincarnation now."


Her husband, Bruce, remains skeptical. "He started researching to disprove what James was telling us, and ended up proving it all," he said. "I think he believes that James Huston's spirit has manifested itself in our son somehow."


The Leiningers have been in touch with Natoma Bay veterans, too.


"We didn't tell the veterans for a long time," Andrea said, "but everyone has a story about having had a spirit visit them. James' sister, Anne Barron, was in California talking to him the day he was killed. Anne believes James' story, because he has provided so much information that only her brother could have known.


"Families of the 21 men who were killed are talking to each other," continued Andrea. "It's brought them together."


The Leiningers plan to attend this year's Natoma Bay reunion and bring their son, James.


Andrea doesn't know why this has happened.


"If he did come back, why? Maybe it was so my husband could write the book about the Natoma Bay," she said. "It helped turn the tide of the war in the Pacific and was one of the most highly decorated carriers, but it hasn't received much recognition."


She said her husband has been working on a chronology of what's happened to James and is researching the book. "He has flight plans from the missions and has spent a year and a half on research. In the introduction, he's writing about how he found out about the ship."


That discovery, through a toddler's fascination with airplanes and nightmares, has led to a segment on national television.


ABC contacted Carol Bowman about her work on children's past lives and James Leininger's experience was the most verifiable, Andrea said. "And we agreed to share his story."
 
James meets his past life sister


In February of 2003 Bruce Leininger made contact with Anne Huston Barron, Huston's sister, who now lives in Los Gatos, Calif. Through several phone conversations, the Leiningers and Ms. Barron became friends, and she agreed to send Bruce photos of her brother during his military service. The packages of photos arrived in February and March of 2003.


In one of the packages was a photo of Huston standing in front of a Corsair fighter plane - the same kind of plane James had mentioned over and over. According to Bruce, interviews with past servicemen and declassified U.S. military records, before Huston joined up with the Natoma Bay and VC-81, he was part of an elite special squadron, the VF-301 Devil's Disciples, from January to August of 1944.


The elite squadron test-flew Corsairs for carrier use, and only 20 pilots were selected for this assignment. However, the VF-301 squadron was disbanded after eight months and Huston was then transferred to VC-81 on Oct. 8, 1944.


When he learned this, Bruce says, all of his skepticism vanished.


"I don't have an answer for this, so I can't explain it either," Bruce says. "Through it all, there has to be an element of faith. There could still be the coincidence of dreaming this all up, but there are odd factors you have to calculate. Lightning can strike once, but when it strikes eight or nine times, you can't say it's a coincidence."


Bruce didn't tell Ms. Barron about his son's supernatural story until later that fall, in October of 2003. When he finally told her about the possibility of her brother's spirit being a part of James, she says she was stunned at first and had to let it all sink in. Then on Oct. 15, 2003, Bruce and Andrea received a letter from her, along with several of Huston's personal effects, that not only said she felt James should have the belongings, but that she truly believed the story.


"This child couldn't know the things he does - he just couldn't - so I believe he is somehow a part of my brother," Ms. Barron says. "These are the things you read about. There must be a reason for it, but I have no hint of what it could be. It's some phenomenon that I don't understand. It all happened nearly 60 years ago. There must be a reason."


Despite not knowing the reason for these coincidences, Ms. Barron is convinced that James Leininger is somehow linked to her lost brother. She now calls the 6-year-old boy "James 3." In turn, he refers to Ms. Barron, who is 86 years old, as his sister.


As Bruce would uncover more information about Huston, without telling James about any of it, the Leiningers would notice more about their son's actions. James had three G.I. Joe dolls and named them Leon, Walter and Billie - names of three pilots who coincidently served with Huston.


According to U.S. Pacific Fleet records, Lt. Leon Stevens Conner, Ensign Walter John Devlin and Ensign Billie Rufus Peeler were among the 21 fatalities from the Natoma Bay. They were also members of the VC-81 air squadron with Huston. When asked why he named the dolls the way he did, Bruce says James answered, "Because they greeted me when I went to heaven.'"


After James said that, Bruce could only leave the room in stunned silence.


James also explained to his father how Corsairs would frequently have flat tires and would always tend to turn to the left. After checking with military historians at the Lone Star Flight Museum in Galveston, Texas, the statement was verified.


Andrea recalls the first time she cooked meatloaf for James, who had never had the meal in his life. After Andrea told him they were having meatloaf for dinner, James said he hadn't had meatloaf since he was on the Natoma Bay. So, Bruce and Andrea contacted several veterans from the carrier, and they learned that meatloaf was a regular meal for the crew.

Andrea Leininger said:
Little James remembered many specific details about his family life. We felt that these details, because they affected the Huston family, were not ours to share and did not disclose them to the public in the Prime Time piece out of respect for their family. James remembered he had a sister Annie, but that she was not his only sister. He said he had a sister who was 4 years older named "Roof". He said Roof was 4 years older than Annie and Annie was 4 years older than him. We later found out the older sister was named RUTH! The 3 Huston children were each 4 years apart. He remembered that his father was an alcoholic and used to "tear up the house". He said when he was 13 they had to put his father in a hospital for 6 weeks because he got drunk and broke some glass in the house. He told us that while his dad was in the hospital, his mom had to be a maid, and when his father got out of the hospital, Annie moved away. This was all later confirmed by Anne, James Huston's surviving sister. Annie said that when her father got out of the hospital, which was like a rehabilitation facility, she moved in with her grandparents several states away. All of James recollections were 100% accurate.
After the September 2004 Natoma Bay reunion, where James got to meet Anne and Jack in person, he seemed to have a sharp decrease in recall and dreams. We felt that he was able to get some kind of closure from the reunion. He didn't recognize his old friends, who are all in their 80's now, but he was dissapointed that they were all old now.
20040911James%20Leininger%20and%20Anne%20Barron.jpg



James Leininger's meeting with Anne Barron, the sister of James Huston.


20040912James%20and%20Jack%20Larsen.jpg



James Leininger's meeting with Jack Larson
 
James 2 = James M. Huston Jr.?
Bruce became obsessed, searching the Internet, combing through military records and interviewing men who served aboard the Natoma Bay.


He said James told him he had been shot down at Iwo Jima. James had also begun signing his crayon drawings "James 3." Bruce soon learned that the only pilot from the squadron killed at Iwo Jima was James M. Huston Jr.


Bruce says James also told him his plane had sustained a direct hit on the engine. Ralph Clarbour, a rear gunner on a U.S. airplane that flew off the Natoma Bay, says his plane was right next to one flown by James M. Huston Jr. during a raid near Iwo Jima on March 3, 1945. Clarbour said he saw Huston's plane struck by anti-aircraft fire. "I would say he was hit head on, right in the middle of the engine," he said.


Some drawings done by James:


20020815%20James%203%20drawing%204.jpg
20020409James%203%20Drawing%202%20for%20Dad.jpg



Treasured Mementos


Bruce says he now believes his son had a past life in which he was James M. Huston Jr. "He came back because he wasn't finished with something." The Leiningers wrote a letter to Huston's sister, Anne Barron, about their little boy. And now she believes it as well. "The child was so convincing in coming up with all the things that there is no way on the world he could know," she said.


But Professor Paul Kurtz of the State University of New York at Buffalo, who heads an organization that investigates claims of the paranormal, says he thinks the parents are "self-deceived." "They're fascinated by the mysterious and they built up a fairy tale," he said.


James' vivid, alleged recollections are starting to fade as he gets older — but among his prized possessions remain two haunting presents sent to him by Barron: a bust of George Washington and a model of a Corsair aircraft. They were among the personal effects of James Huston sent home after the war.


"He appears to have experienced something that I don't think is unique, but the way it's been revealed is quite astounding," Bruce said. Asked if the idea that James may have been someone else changes his or his wife's feeling about their son, Bruce said: "It doesn't change how we think. I don't look at him and say, 'That's not my boy.' That's my boy."
 
What are Dr. Jim Tucker's perspectives?


Is Dr. Jim Tucker (who is carrying-on the work of the late Dr. Ian Stevenson) studying the Leninger case?


Dr. Stevenson's decades of case-studies have attempted to discern a "six degrees of separation" between incarnations e.g., were there connections between relatives, friends, colleagues, geographic locations etc.?


Have any attempts been made to discern six-degress of separation between the Leninger's and Huston's over the years?


Marc
 
Scholarly article


Hi Deborah,


I just read the book by the Leiningers, Soul Survivor. It really is wonderful and very convincing.


I wonder whether anyone has already written a scholarly article about the case, in which all the individual statements and behaviors of James would be analysed systematically.


Best wishes,


Titus
 
Hi Titus,


I don't think so but I will ask Carol. It would be a great addition to an already fascinating case.:thumbsup:
 
Titus Rivas said:
Hi Deborah,
I just read the book by the Leiningers, Soul Survivor. It really is wonderful and very convincing.


I wonder whether anyone has already written a scholarly article about the case, in which all the individual statements and behaviors of James would be analysed systematically.


Best wishes,


Titus
Hi, Titus


there are some criticisms about the case here:


http://skeptico.blogs.com/skeptico/2005/07/reincarnation_a.html


Best wishes.
 
I checked out the link and find it narrow minded and defensive. I wonder what they are defending? ;) Statements such as this are hardly scientifically based. To me there is a big difference between critical thinking and skepticism, evidence and conjecture. Carol never leads a child to their memories. EVER!

Carol Bowman asked him leading questions and encouraged his fantasy at every turn. Being a young child, he loved making up fantasies of being a pilot, to go with the toys he had been given. But they were just stories.
When I saw this I was ROTFLMAO. :laugh: Is this guy serious? A three year old saw the name of the boat in one of this fathers books- and read it? But then he says he didn't say the whole name? :rolleyes::rolleyes:

“Natoma” is the name of a ship he could no doubt have seen in one of his father’s books. But “Natoma” is not quite “Natoma Bay” - and did he say “Natoma” or just something similar? We’ll never know. Only “John Larson” can’t be explained easily......
Thanks for posting it ---- ;) It is an outdated July 2005 blog. Still interesting to read through though.
 
Thanks for the link Vitor :thumbsup:


I also read the blog and although I always have an open mind to everybodys' opinion, whether they be a skeptic or a believer, I found this article to be very weak.


The whole argument seems to be based around the fact that James visited the aircraft museum at the age of 3, BEFORE his nightmares of being shot down began. For me personally, this only reinforces the suggestion that he is the reincarnated WWII pilot that he and his parents claim him to be. The past life memories were clearly triggered by the museum visit, whereas the blog suggests that the nightmares began BECAUSE of it. I'm sorry, but I fail to see the likelihood of a static aircraft, just sitting there, engines silent, causing a 3 year old to have nightmares.... unless being around them, caused him to remember other, more 'unpleasant' experiences with them.
 
Back
Top