• Thank you to Carol and Steve Bowman, the forum owners, for our new upgrade!

Is balance really necessary?

TheDivineOne

Should've been born a girl...
Over at another site that only partly deals with reincarnation (not as much as this one) I posted this thread regarding cross-gender reincarnations. The one person who replied said something really interesting. I'll just copy-and-paste exactly what I said and what Sandalwood said word for word. Yes, lol, I'm also TheDivineOne on spiritualforums.com btw.

TheDivineOne from spiritualforums.com said:
I'm still struggling to find peace in my transgender situation, and in that nobody can give me a 100% confirmation that in my next lifetime i will be born female.

But for the most part when I talk to someone about the topic of reincarnation, I can't help but to feel all these feelings of anger, resentment, bitterness, and rage when someone born male in this life tells me he remembers being a female in the previous life. I feel all those feelings because I was born male in this life and should've been born female. I'm in the middle of transitioning.

Again, I really want to know that I will be born female in my next life. The only positive thing that being transgender has gotten me was a desire to come back and live another earthly life. I don't want to go to Heaven or Hell. I don't care about learning any "lessons".

I want to know what it's like to menstruate, to give birth, and to know what it's like to be a fully-fledged female... from birth to death. I just want what was taken from me.

After two past-life regression meditations, I remember being a female in my previous life and I also saw that I was murdered. Having seen all that, whoever killed me in my past life, I have nothing but hatred in my heart against my past-life killer, whereas if i were born female, i wouldn't care one way or the other how i died last time or that i was murdered.

I feel stuck... so out of place. I'm at the point where I'm waiting for it to be over but not knowing when is really torturous.

But I can't help but to wonder, if you were one gender in the past life and now a different gender in this one, don't you miss your past-life gender? Don't you have a specific preference for what your sex is? I would've thought that it would explain many people being transgender.

Then sandalwood replied...

sandalwood from spiritualforums.com said:
Sex and sexuality can change with every incarnation
And your next life likely won't have the same gender preference
If in one life you are female
And have a strong expression of femininity
Then it is actually likely to be born male
Your spirit seeks balance of energy
And we require both the masculine and feminine aspects
I have been born both male and female before
Both gay and straight
A variety is common

I take this to mean that if i'm female in one life and have that strong expression of femininity then that's why i'm likely to be born male in another life? I know this is another of the many threads i've already made on here about my desire to be female in this life and the next but it's just that I'm hearing from several different sources, including this community, about the whole thing about a soul needing balance. I'm just still trying to make sense of it all. That's all.

I also read in another site that a particular soul can have up to seven consecutive lives in one gender. Is that rule really a thing? A lot of these sites claiming to know a thing or two about reincarnation tend to contradict and conflict each other that it's hard to determine which site is legit and which isn't.
 
I don't think we know what the "rules" if any, are. There are a lot of opinions and, as you say, many are contradicting. Also, most people have read the same books and keep quoting whatever Michael Newton or Brian Weiss says. But many of those books are based on hypnosis regressions. The subjects are all from first world countries and can also afford to have expensive regressions done. That leaves out a HUGE percentage of the global population.

Other people base their opinions on their own spontaneous memories/experience. But that doesn't necessarily mean the same experiences apply to everyone. It applies to each person that personally experienced it. Some people report having a wide variety of PLs in various cultures and sometimes male, sometimes female. Others report many PLs in similar or closely related cultures and and/or a preference for one gender over another. That's why I say we don't know what the "rules", if any, are for sure.

Remember, the Dalai Lama has spent his last 14 incarnations as a Tibetan male Buddhist.
 
Hi DO,

I ditto Isha on this (generally speaking), but would once again point you towards Ian Stevenson's site and findings (which I gave you on a previous post somewhere on this board waaaaay back). Stevenson's work is almost all third world spontaneous memory in children. He found clear trends of people tending to be fairly consistent over several incarnations and then a time or two as the opposite. (As I recall, the average was one or two out of ten going the opposite way). The reasons given for this by "experts" are guesswork so far as I know, such as "balance", learning to see things from the opposite viewpoint, etc. though there is some grounds for such speculations. Stevenson also found that the incarnations where there was a cross-over from the norm tended to be ones where there was some gender issues such as homosexuality or transsexuality. Consequently, given the data, I take this to be your cross-over and (from this) think it likely that your next is liable to be back into your prior gender. As usual though, this is just (like the others noted above) an educated guess, but the percentages seem to favor this result.

I have my own theory about what may be happening in some cross-overs. I haven't tried to do any kind of statistical analysis, but it seems to me that they often follow some kind of really miserable life, disillusionment and/or death where the proximate reason for the misery seems to be tied into a particular gender--such as I wouldn't have been raped and killed, if I'd been male, or I wouldn't have been drafted and died horribly in battle if I'd been female. Given your background I wonder whether this was a factor. BTW--I think one of the things learned in the cross-over is that it ain't any better (or at least "I'm not happier") on the other side of the divide. So, if that was something you were intended to learn--you definitely got it!

Cordially,
S&S
 
Hi, The Divine One. I basically agree with Isha and SeaAndSky here, but answering your question, does balance matter for a soul? My opinion is: probably not. You are seeing for yourself, everyone has a theory, but the only thing we know for sure is that nobody knows. In the case of sexuality, well, who is to decide if you have to be born male or female? Who says one is "better" than the other? Who says you have to "balance" something because you have decided to stick to one sex for a million years? Don't many of us reincarnate in the same race over and over again, save exceptions? Why should it be different with gender?

My position is that we choose one depending on what we want to achieve or the experiences we want to live. You are having problems with your gender, the same way you could be having problems being a slave and wishing for freedom, something that you would likely never have in that life. I think there is no need to look further. Do what you feel is right to be happy, as long as you don't harm others, and learn to live with those things you can't change. Whatever may come in the future, will come.
 
Eowyn and S&S, I love what both of you have written! You both put it in better words than I could. To be honest, I was "afraid' to go further with what I really thought, but you both said it. Thank you.

When I started reading about reincarnation (before the Newton and Weiss books came out) what I read sounded conflicting and confusing. Then I found Ian Stevenson. He was a breath of fresh air(!) and everything sounded "right" to me. After that, I basically compared everything I read to his work. And still do.
 
I agree with Eowyn...

Having been through this myself though and gotten over it (as much as possible anyway), it saddens me to see so many people focus on what they feel that can't have rather than what they can; that is experience, knowledge, perspective, understanding and even purpose.

Everyone's incarnation is personal and individual, so we can't give answers. It is hard, I will say that. I can absolutely melt with envy over a pair of shoes or someone's outfit or even the simple task of fixing one's hair. It's tough, but not having my son would be tougher. Knowing what I know now does make it better, but not 100%. It takes guts. I'm sure just as well when i'm female again, I'll have some complaint about not being male.

There will always be some other grass or pasture out there to envy. It's best to look within to find purpose and happiness.
 
Having been through this myself though and gotten over it (as much as possible anyway), it saddens me to see so many people focus on what they feel that can't have rather than what they can; that is experience, knowledge, perspective, understanding and even purpose.

Everyone's incarnation is personal and individual, so we can't give answers. It is hard, I will say that. I can absolutely melt with envy over a pair of shoes or someone's outfit or even the simple task of fixing one's hair. It's tough, but not having my son would be tougher. Knowing what I know now does make it better, but not 100%. It takes guts. I'm sure just as well when i'm female again, I'll have some complaint about not being male.

There will always be some other grass or pasture out there to envy. It's best to look within to find purpose and happiness.

While it's very noble of you to value your son over your womanhood (or lack thereof), as you said so yourself, everyone's life is personal and individual. I value my womanhood very much and you saying things like that is the reason why I refuse to procreate using my male reproductive organs. I want to experience pregnancy and menstruation, and have a baby... as a woman, and until it becomes possible for transwomen to have babies (provided i'm still young enough) i'm not having children.

I hate not being a mother to my non-existing daughter but I care more about my femaleness that I want back, and maybe that's why i shouldn't have children regardless what sex organs i have or don't have.

Hi, The Divine One. I basically agree with Isha and SeaAndSky here, but answering your question, does balance matter for a soul? My opinion is: probably not. You are seeing for yourself, everyone has a theory, but the only thing we know for sure is that nobody knows. In the case of sexuality, well, who is to decide if you have to be born male or female? Who says one is "better" than the other? Who says you have to "balance" something because you have decided to stick to one sex for a million years? Don't many of us reincarnate in the same race over and over again, save exceptions? Why should it be different with gender?

My position is that we choose one depending on what we want to achieve or the experiences we want to live. You are having problems with your gender, the same way you could be having problems being a slave and wishing for freedom, something that you would likely never have in that life. I think there is no need to look further. Do what you feel is right to be happy, as long as you don't harm others, and learn to live with those things you can't change. Whatever may come in the future, will come.

Here's my thing: many people have a position on souls needing to live different lives from all perspectives. For example, a particular soul being human, an animal, male, female, Black, White, Asian, Hispanic, etc. and so that's where the whole "balance" thing came into play.

Just like many reincarnation believers have a position on the notion that souls "choose" the gender, the race, or bodies that we have for each incarnation that i'm still not sure i'm ready to believe quite yet but if that's the case then i guess i will be female in my next life and in many of my consecutive lifetimes.

Keep in mind that I have a huge problem with having been born male and always will for the rest of this life. I will say what i said in another thread on this or some other site. The only thing being transgender has every gotten me was the desire to come back to Earth when i die... because i want to be a female, not a male. Not only that, i want to be female in many consecutive lifetimes. Being transgender makes me want to believe in reincarnation because i want to know that i will have a chance to experience what being an actual female is like, from the womb to the tomb. It's primarily the only reason why i care about reincarnation because taking my femaleness back is all that matters to me and all that ever will matter to me... and it is destroying me inside that there is no way of knowing for sure after this lifetime i'll come back and be born a female.

I'm still feeling like committing suicide if it means i'll be born female in my next life.
 
Note that it's not letting me edit the last post so i'll have to make a new one. This is a bit tricky.......

I've not lifted a finger for the Ian Stevenson book is because as you guys or someone else said when i first came here, no one can confirm for me for sure if i will be female in my next life, at which point you were under the impression i wanted to know if i were female in my past life, when in fact, i care more about being female in the next life than my past life. Follow? If you guys can't confirm it for me, not only will that contribute to the distress but what makes either of you so sure that Stevenson can?

Remember, the Dalai Lama has spent his last 14 incarnations as a Tibetan male Buddhist.

I'm guessing his soul's gender preference is male? I personally couldn't imagine that.

I ditto Isha on this (generally speaking), but would once again point you towards Ian Stevenson's site and findings (which I gave you on a previous post somewhere on this board waaaaay back). Stevenson's work is almost all third world spontaneous memory in children. He found clear trends of people tending to be fairly consistent over several incarnations and then a time or two as the opposite. (As I recall, the average was one or two out of ten going the opposite way). The reasons given for this by "experts" are guesswork so far as I know, such as "balance", learning to see things from the opposite viewpoint, etc. though there is some grounds for such speculations. Stevenson also found that the incarnations where there was a cross-over from the norm tended to be ones where there was some gender issues such as homosexuality or transsexuality. Consequently, given the data, I take this to be your cross-over and (from this) think it likely that your next is liable to be back into your prior gender. As usual though, this is just (like the others noted above) an educated guess, but the percentages seem to favor this result.

Well... as you might've suspected, i've not lifted a finger for the Ian Stevenson book because as you or someone else so kindly pointed out when i came here, no one can confirm for me for sure if or not i'll be born female in my next life. I'm guessing it's because everyone was under the assumption that i wanted to know if i were female in my past life (remember my first thread?) when in fact i care more about being female in my very next lifetime and ascertaining that now. If you guys can't confirm it for me, then what makes you entirely sure Stevenson will?

But to be fair, it would be interesting that someone born female, and not transgender, was born a male-to-female transgender in her past life, and was a female in her life before that. I've read stories of women who said they wanted to be born male in their next life and actually were. I hope they all ring true because being born female in my next life would mean beyond absolutely everything to me!
 
Here's my thing: many people have a position on souls needing to live different lives from all perspectives. For example, a particular soul being human, an animal, male, female, Black, White, Asian, Hispanic, etc. and so that's where the whole "balance" thing came into play.

Just like many reincarnation believers have a position on the notion that souls "choose" the gender, the race, or bodies that we have for each incarnation that i'm still not sure i'm ready to believe quite yet but if that's the case then i guess i will be female in my next life and in many of my consecutive lifetimes.

Yeah, I know what you meant, and I was trying to make you think about it. We have to live things from different perspectives, I absolutely buy that. But I don't think it's an obligation. It's a fact (at least that's what has been observed in many Stevenson's cases and in the accounts of many anonymous people like those you find in this forum) that souls tend to stick to what is familiar to them, so, once you've been born white, you'll probably want to be white again. But maybe we don't always choose, what if it's just a random thing? I've been mostly white in most of my lives, but I also remember lives as Asian and black. Whatever the case, it's quite likely you will be born a female sooner or later, it's just a matter of statistics and biology, so why should you worry so much?

Now, to clarify the matter of balance: fortunately, the differences between genders are disappearing (of course, depending on the country, the progression is different). In the past, being a woman would make you more prone to become a victim of many types of abuse, you could easily die in childbirth, your role choices were quite reduced and if you wanted to do different things, you would have to fight a great deal. The challenges you'd have to face were different to a man's, but if we accept the hypothesis we choose our circumstances, well, maybe you chose to be a woman to do all that! But I still don't see why you should "balance" anything here becoming a man in your next life, it just depends on what you want to do next. I think we have a tendency to believe souls are in a linear spiritual progression, that is, what we live in a given life is closely tied to what we did or experienced in other lives, so if we were male, now we have to be female; if we did something wrong, now we have to "compensate" and try to do right (because of course, if we don't, we are condemning ourselves somehow); if we were poor, now we have to be rich. You get it. No, I don't buy this. I think every life is lived independently. There are carry-overs, of course, because obviously, we are the result of our experiences and past life emotions linger, but what we have lived before, DON'T determine the events in our next life. It's our reactions to those events what matters. So, there's nothing to balance really. You just draw your conclusions from your previous lives and use what you have learned to live your next lives, that's all.

Keep in mind that I have a huge problem with having been born male and always will for the rest of this life. I will say what i said in another thread on this or some other site. The only thing being transgender has every gotten me was the desire to come back to Earth when i die... because i want to be a female, not a male. Not only that, i want to be female in many consecutive lifetimes. Being transgender makes me want to believe in reincarnation because i want to know that i will have a chance to experience what being an actual female is like, from the womb to the tomb. It's primarily the only reason why i care about reincarnation because taking my femaleness back is all that matters to me and all that ever will matter to me... and it is destroying me inside that there is no way of knowing for sure after this lifetime i'll come back and be born a female.

I'm still feeling like committing suicide if it means i'll be born female in my next life.


No one here can assure you that you will be born female next time, that's true, because none of us really know how things work on the other side. Probably you will choose. Could be that you have that strong desire to be a woman and experience life as a woman because you were robbed of fulfilling those desires in your past life. At least it sounds as something traumatic to me. But I think you only have to be patient. I think the world is also filled of women who are quite tired of menstruation and childbirth (I wonder why uterus donors don't exist yet, I would gladly give you mine), but we just were dealt these cards, want it or not. Have you ever considered the possibility you chose to be a transgender woman to live and learn from the experience, to understand the issues that arise when you are born with this condition, to fight society's prejudice about it, to help people with the same problem, once you've gotten over your own issues? I think that once you've accepted your cards, you'll start to see the positive things, and you'll be able to play smartly with them. And yes, I understand how dark your prospects are right now, I know it's not easy.

Or... who says you won't be born as a female, because you desire it so much, and then come back as a transgender? The possibilities are endless. But my advice, like I said before, is: just be patient. Every life is a gift, believe me, or at least an opportunity you must not reject, so don't throw it away.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Lovely reply Eowyn.

But I think you only have to be patient...

But my advice, like I said before, is: just be patient. Every life is a gift, believe me, or at least an opportunity you must not reject, so don't throw it away.

I love it that people can have discussions like this and in such a great, loving and gentle way. But being able to speak the truth. These things are never simple.

I want to experience pregnancy and menstruation, and have a baby

You will. Of course you will... Be careful what you wish for TDO. :)
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I know what you meant, and I was trying to make you think about it. We have to live things from different perspectives, I absolutely buy that. But I don't think it's an obligation. It's a fact (at least that's what has been observed in many Stevenson's cases and in the accounts of many anonymous people like those you find in this forum) that souls tend to stick to what is familiar to them, so, once you've been born white, you'll probably want to be white again. But maybe we don't always choose, what if it's just a random thing? I've been mostly white in most of my lives, but I also remember lives as Asian and black. Whatever the case, it's quite likely you will be born a female sooner or later, it's just a matter of statistics and biology, so why should you worry so much?

The thing about it is, I don't know much about my past lives. Thanks to the 2 past life regressions i did do. I know that according to them i was a black female in my past life and i'm black in my current life as well. I'm still trying to figure out why if that's the case i couldn't take my femaleness with me into this life too. I just want to be female in my very next lifetime, right after this one and in the one after that.

Now, to clarify the matter of balance: fortunately, the differences between genders are disappearing (of course, depending on the country, the progression is different). In the past, being a woman would make you more prone to become a victim of many types of abuse, you could easily die in childbirth, your role choices were quite reduced and if you wanted to do different things, you would have to fight a great deal. The challenges you'd have to face were different to a man's, but if we accept the hypothesis we choose our circumstances, well, maybe you chose to be a woman to do all that! But I still don't see why you should "balance" anything here becoming a man in your next life, it just depends on what you want to do next. I think we have a tendency to believe souls are in a linear spiritual progression, that is, what we live in a given life is closely tied to what we did or experienced in other lives, so if we were male, now we have to be female; if we did something wrong, now we have to "compensate" and try to do right (because of course, if we don't, we are condemning ourselves somehow); if we were poor, now we have to be rich. You get it. No, I don't buy this. I think every life is lived independently. There are carry-overs, of course, because obviously, we are the result of our experiences and past life emotions linger, but what we have lived before, DON'T determine the events in our next life. It's our reactions to those events what matters. So, there's nothing to balance really. You just draw your conclusions from your previous lives and use what you have learned to live your next lives, that's all.

I sort of figured someone would say that sooner or later. I would've liked to have known that (and i did do a thread on here asking about this but unfortunately failed to get a solid answer) an unfulfilled desire from one lifetime would be carried over into the next. A lot of reincarnation believers have this solid belief that a person who commits suicide will only end up repeating that life into the next so I would think dreams and desires work the same way as well... or so i hope... and so i feel my being a male-to-female transgender means the strong possibility of being born female in my next life.

Also people tend to have this notion that life on Earth is some kind of "school" where we're here to learn "lessons" or something of that sort. Lest we forget we live in a world where exists pain, death, racism, sexism, crime, rape, alcoholism, abuse, atrocities, among other horrible things. Some might be wondering why I would want to come back to a world like that, regardless of my gender? The thing about it is, I don't, really. I just want to live a lifetime as a female since i already have a life in which i was born male. I find myself constantly wondering what this life would be like if i were born a female... without being transgender.

Could be that you have that strong desire to be a woman and experience life as a woman because you were robbed of fulfilling those desires in your past life. At least it sounds as something traumatic to me.

Some time after my second past life regression, i got the epiphany that in my past life as a woman, i was murdered. I think i was murdered in my past life. I don't know for sure. That might be it. Also, as a young child in this life, as confusing as this might sound, I wanted to know what it was like to be girl. I thought it would be interesting if i were a girl in this life. Could it be that i forgot what it's like to be a female? I don't know. I just know that i'm looking for way to make sense of all this.

But I think you only have to be patient. I think the world is also filled of women who are quite tired of menstruation and childbirth (I wonder why uterus donors don't exist yet, I would gladly give you mine), but we just were dealt these cards, want it or not. Have you ever considered the possibility you chose to be a transgender woman to live and learn from the experience, to understand the issues that arise when you are born with this condition, to fight society's prejudice about it, to help people with the same problem, once you've gotten over your own issues? I think that once you've accepted your cards, you'll start to see the positive things, and you'll be able to play smartly with them. And yes, I understand how dark your prospects are right now, I know it's not easy.

Or... who says you won't be born as a female, because you desire it so much, and then come back as a transgender? The possibilities are endless. But my advice, like I said before, is: just be patient. Every life is a gift, believe me, or at least an opportunity you must not reject, so don't throw it away.

*giggles a little*

It's crazy because i never would've guessed a stranger on the internet would say something to me via an internet forum that would have a positive impact on me. You know what else is crazy? I actually came to a point in my life where i accept myself, that i'm transgender and my transition to female is as close as i'll get to being female in this life. Who knows? Maybe i was curious as to what it's like to be a transgender woman. What's interesting though is that when my mom was pregnant with me, my dad wanted a girl but my mom wanted a girl... so... yeah.

As much as i accept myself my depression always finds a way to take its toll on me and darken my mind, clouding my judgement. I would love to take your advice but it just scares me, as far as my depression goes, that my depression will win the fight against me... for me to remain calm and composed and just see how things play out. But then again I am in therapy and taking antidepressants so... yeah...

Thanks for your lovely response, E!
 
Hi DO,

Hang in there! What you've found by this time is that we can't give you 100% answers on just about anything, but there are still a lot of nice, well-meaning people here who'll do there best to help--and that's rare in this world. Plus, though we can't give you absolute answers, we can often give you consensus answers that express a high degree of probability. That's about as good an answer as you can get in this world on just about anything, including tomorrow's weather.

Cordially,
S&S
 
I'm really, really glad I could help you, TheDivineOne.

A lot of reincarnation believers have this solid belief that a person who commits suicide will only end up repeating that life into the next so I would think dreams and desires work the same way as well... or so i hope... and so i feel my being a male-to-female transgender means the strong possibility of being born female in my next life.

No, no! The part of the suicide is a myth, I can tell you (I committed suicide). Unfulfilled dreams and desires, all kind of traumas, mental patterns you created as a result of your experiences... all that do carry over, regardless of the kind of death you had, though obviously if you had a traumatic life/death, this is more likely to happen.

Also people tend to have this notion that life on Earth is some kind of "school" where we're here to learn "lessons" or something of that sort. Lest we forget we live in a world where exists pain, death, racism, sexism, crime, rape, alcoholism, abuse, atrocities, among other horrible things. Some might be wondering why I would want to come back to a world like that, regardless of my gender? The thing about it is, I don't, really. I just want to live a lifetime as a female since i already have a life in which i was born male. I find myself constantly wondering what this life would be like if i were born a female... without being transgender.

Nice, you put it quite simple, because it is. The world is what we make of it, nothing more. And you learn, if you want. Most of us just want to LIVE, with everything that implies, both the good and the bad. And there are also plenty of wonderful things to enjoy.

Some time after my second past life regression, i got the epiphany that in my past life as a woman, i was murdered. I think i was murdered in my past life. I don't know for sure. That might be it. Also, as a young child in this life, as confusing as this might sound, I wanted to know what it was like to be girl. I thought it would be interesting if i were a girl in this life. Could it be that i forgot what it's like to be a female? I don't know. I just know that i'm looking for way to make sense of all this.

I know of a case very similar to yours, in which a young girl was murdered and in the next life he's a man with transgender issues. So, maybe we're into something here. When doubts, follow your intuition.

*giggles a little*

It's crazy because i never would've guessed a stranger on the internet would say something to me via an internet forum that would have a positive impact on me. You know what else is crazy? I actually came to a point in my life where i accept myself, that i'm transgender and my transition to female is as close as i'll get to being female in this life. Who knows? Maybe i was curious as to what it's like to be a transgender woman. What's interesting though is that when my mom was pregnant with me, my dad wanted a girl but my mom wanted a girl... so... yeah.

As much as i accept myself my depression always finds a way to take its toll on me and darken my mind, clouding my judgement. I would love to take your advice but it just scares me, as far as my depression goes, that my depression will win the fight against me... for me to remain calm and composed and just see how things play out. But then again I am in therapy and taking antidepressants so... yeah...

Thanks for your lovely response, E!

I'm so glad you felt better, at least for a while. I know what you mean with depression, I'm always fighting against it too, maybe that's the reason I understand what you're going through. Depression is tough, it really takes you down and don't allow you to see how strong you are. Just try to see the positive side, sometimes it's hard, but you have reached this far, haven't you? Will you let depression stop you now?
 
Back
Top